A Comprehensive Guide to New York Eviction Laws and Process in 2024

Eviction is a complex and often challenging process for both landlords and tenants in New York. With its unique set of laws and regulations, the Empire State provides specific protections and procedures that all parties must understand and follow.

Recent legislative changes, including the “Good Cause Eviction Law,” have affected property owners and residents alike. These new regulations require valid reasons for evictions and substantial rent increases, enhancing tenant rights and providing more stability in lease renewals.

This guide aims to explain the eviction process in New York, offering valuable insights for landlords while also highlighting important tenant protections. We'll explore the intricacies of local eviction laws, from the grounds for removal to the step-by-step legal procedures. Additionally, we'll discuss alternatives to eviction, the importance of proper recordkeeping, and key rights that tenants hold during this process.

Whether you're a property owner seeking to understand your obligations or a resident interested in your rights, this comprehensive overview will provide you with essential information to navigate the eviction landscape in New York. Our goal is to equip all parties with the knowledge needed to approach these challenging situations with clarity and understanding.

Common reasons for eviction in New York

In New York, landlords can evict tenants for several legally valid reasons. Recent changes in eviction law, particularly the Good Cause Eviction Law, emphasize the necessity for landlords to provide valid reasons for eviction or rent hikes. It’s important to understand each reason, as the process and requirements vary based on the circumstances. Below are the most common grounds for eviction and the steps landlords must follow.

1: Failure to pay rent

One of the primary reasons for eviction is non-payment of rent. Timely rent payment is important in the landlord-tenant relationship; if the tenant pays on time, they avoid legal complications. New York law is clear on what constitutes late payment and the steps landlords can take.

• Rent is deemed late if received more than five days after the due date. At this point, landlords can take action.
• If the tenant doesn't pay by the sixth day, the landlord can issue a 14-day notice to pay or vacate. This gives the tenant 14 days to either settle the outstanding rent or leave the property.
• If the tenant fails to comply within the notice period, the landlord can file for eviction. This process typically involves filing a petition in housing court to regain possession of the rental unit.

2: Lease violations

Tenants can also be evicted for breaking the terms of their rental agreement. These violations may include the following:

• Smoking in non-smoking areas.
• Keeping unapproved pets.
• Causing damage to the property.

Landlords must provide tenants with a 30-day notice, allowing them time to either fix the violation or move out. If the tenant fails to correct the issue within the 30-day period, the landlord can begin eviction proceedings.

3: Expired lease/holdover tenancy

One common reason for eviction in New York is when a tenant stays in the rental property after their lease has expired without a renewal — this is known as a “holdover tenancy.” In these cases, the landlord has the legal right to ask the tenant to vacate the property.

Landlords aren't required to renew a tenant’s lease when it ends. If they choose not to renew, they must provide the tenant with a formal notice to vacate. The amount of notice a landlord must give before starting the eviction process depends on how long the tenant has lived in the rental:

• Less than 1 year of occupancy: 30 days’ notice.

• 1 to 2 years of occupancy: 60 days’ notice.

• More than 2 years of occupancy: 90 days’ notice.

If the tenant does not leave by the end of the notice period, the landlord can file for eviction in court to regain possession of the property. However, owner occupancy can restrict evicting certain tenants, such as seniors or disabled individuals, unless an equivalent rental option is provided.

4: Illegal use of premises

Illegal activities conducted on the rental property can lead to immediate eviction. Examples include the following:

• Drug manufacturing or distribution.
• Running an illegal business.
• Engaging in activities that threaten the safety of other tenants or neighbors.

In cases of illegal activity, landlords can move forward with the eviction process without giving the tenant advance notice. However, they must still file a formal eviction lawsuit in court.

5: Nuisance or disturbance

Tenants who repeatedly disrupt other tenants or create a public nuisance may also face eviction. Here are some examples:

• Excessive noise at all hours.
• Harassing other tenants or neighbors.
• Engaging in activities that interfere with the peaceful enjoyment of the property by others.

After providing the tenant with written notice, landlords can seek eviction if the disruptive behavior does not stop.

6: Engaging in criminal activity

Criminal behavior is another serious reason for eviction. If a tenant engages in criminal activity on or near the rental property, landlords can take immediate action.

In contrast to most other reasons for eviction, landlords are not required to provide written notice before filing for eviction if the tenant is involved in criminal activity. However, landlords must still follow formal legal procedures to regain possession of the property.

Remember, in all cases except criminal activity, landlords must issue proper written notices before proceeding with eviction. Failure to do so can delay the process or result in the eviction being dismissed by the court.

Eviction is a legal process, and landlords must file a case in housing court if a tenant does not comply with the notice. The court will then determine whether eviction is justified and issue an order for the tenant to vacate.

Steps for filing an eviction in New York

Now that we have discussed the reasons for eviction, let’s move on to the process itself. To file an eviction in New York, landlords must follow these steps:

1. Serve the appropriate written notice to the tenant:

• For non-payment of rent: 14-day notice to pay or quit.
• For lease violations: 10-day notice to cure or quit.
• For terminating a month-to-month tenancy: 30-day or 60-day notice to terminate tenancy.

2. File an unlawful detainer lawsuit if the tenant does not comply with the notice:

• File the lawsuit in the court where the rental property is located.
• Serve the petition notice 10-17 days before the scheduled hearing.

3. Attend the court hearing:

• The court date is typically set when filing the eviction petition.
• Either party can request a 14-day adjournment.
• If the tenant fails to appear, the court will proceed with the case.
• The court date, as noted in the "Notice of Petition," is important because it indicates when the eviction case will be heard and the timeline for serving legal documents prior to that date.

4. Obtain a judgment:

• If the court rules in the landlord’s favor, a writ of possession will be issued.

5. Issue a warrant of eviction to the tenant:

• This final notice gives the tenant a period (from a few hours up to 14 days) to vacate the property.

6. If necessary, obtain a forcible entry and detainer order:

• This allows law enforcement to remove the tenant if they refuse to leave

Throughout this process, landlords must provide proper documentation, which includes the following:

• The original lease agreement.
• Copies of all notices served.
• Proof of lease violations or non-payment of rent
• Any other relevant evidence supporting the eviction case.

It’s important to note that landlords cannot use self-help methods to evict tenants, such as changing locks or shutting off utilities. The eviction must be carried out through proper legal channels

New York eviction timeline

The New York eviction process follows a legal path that varies based on several factors. While the exact timeline can differ, here’s an overview of what influences the duration:

Notice periods

The first step is serving the tenant with the appropriate notice based on the reason for eviction. As mentioned previously, this can range from 14 days for non-payment of rent to 60 days for terminating a month-to-month. 

Court filing and hearing

If the tenant does not comply with the notice, the landlord files an eviction lawsuit. From there, court schedules and tenant responses determine how long the process takes. Hearings are usually set within 10-17 days after filing, but any adjournments or appeals could extend the timeline.

Judgment and Writ of Possession

Once the court rules in favor of the landlord, the tenant receives a writ of possession. The time the tenant has to vacate varies, typically between a few hours and up to 14 days. Contested cases may take longer, especially if appeals are filed.

Factors that influence the timeline

The duration of the eviction process depends on the following:

• The reason for eviction (e.g., non-payment of rent, lease violation).
• Whether the tenant contests the eviction or requests adjournments.
• The court’s schedule and backlog, particularly in busier jurisdictions like New York City.
• Any delays from appeals or tenant defenses.

On average, an uncontested eviction may take 4-6 weeks from serving the initial notice to the tenant’s removal. However, contested cases or those involving appeals can extend the process to several months.

Remember, it’s important for landlords to follow the legal process and avoid self-help eviction methods like changing locks or shutting off utilities — such actions are illegal in New York.

Why good recordkeeping matters in evictions

Effective recordkeeping helps ensure a smooth and legally compliant eviction process in New York. It offers landlords the necessary documentation to support their case and provides a clear trail that demonstrates adherence to local laws.

Good records provide legal safeguards by offering concrete proof that you’ve followed all required steps, from issuing notices to filing paperwork on time. They also protect against potential false claims or tenant disputes, giving you a solid foundation in court.

Beyond legal protection, good recordkeeping simplifies the eviction process. Organized documentation ensures that all communications, notices, and deadlines are properly tracked and easily accessible during legal proceedings. Key records to maintain include lease agreements, payment histories, correspondence, maintenance logs, and visual evidence of the property’s condition.

To manage records effectively, leverage technology by storing files securely in cloud services, develop a logical filing system, and promptly document all tenant interactions. Retaining records for several years post-eviction is also a good idea to safeguard against future claims.

Check out Azibo’s document storage capabilities.

What happens after the court ruling?

Once the court has made its decision in an eviction case, a series of steps unfold. This process ensures that both landlords and tenants understand their rights and responsibilities following the judgment.

Judgment and Warrant of Possession

If the judge rules in favor of the landlord, two important documents are issued:

1. Judgment for eviction: This official decision may include any monetary awards for unpaid rent and legal costs.
2. Warrant of possession: This legal document authorizes the removal of the tenant from the rental property.

Notice period and tenant options

Following the court's decision, tenants are given time to respond:

• The sheriff must provide the tenant with at least 14 days' written notice before executing the warrant.
• During this period, tenants have two main options:
  1. Vacate the property voluntarily.
  2. Request a "stay" or delay of the eviction, if they can show good cause.

Physical eviction process

If the tenant doesn't leave within the given timeframe, the following will occur:

1. The landlord can request law enforcement to carry out the physical eviction.
2. A sheriff, constable, or marshal will forcibly remove the tenant and their belongings from the property.

Handling tenant's belongings

After the eviction, there may be specific procedures for dealing with any items left behind by the tenant. However, the exact details of this process can vary — its worth checking your local laws for exact instructions. 

Preventing eviction: alternatives for landlords and tenants

In New York, both landlords and tenants can take steps to prevent eviction and explore alternatives. Here are some strategies and options:

Strategies for landlords

• Communicate early and often with tenants, especially if rent is late.
• Offer payment plans for tenants experiencing temporary financial hardship.
• Address maintenance issues promptly and conduct regular inspections.
• Keep detailed records of all communications, agreements, and payments.

Strategies for tenants

• Pay rent on time and communicate immediately if unable to pay.
• Follow all lease terms and seek permission before making changes to the property.
• Report maintenance issues promptly and in writing.
• Research rental assistance programs and consult tenant rights organizations if needed.

Alternatives to eviction

1. Mediation: Use third-party mediators to facilitate discussions and find mutually beneficial solutions outside of court.
2. Cash for keys: Landlords offer tenants money to move out voluntarily, which can be faster and less expensive than formal eviction.
3. Lease termination agreement: Negotiate an early end to the lease without penalties, allowing tenants to move out on agreed terms.
4. Subletting or assignment: If allowed by the lease, tenants can find someone to take over their rental obligations.
5. Rental assistance programs: Both parties can explore government or non-profit programs offering financial support for rent payments.
6. Temporary rent reduction: Landlords may consider lowering rent temporarily to help tenants stay in the property.

By exploring these options and maintaining open communication, landlords and tenants can often find alternatives to eviction that benefit both parties. Addressing issues early and seeking professional advice when necessary can help navigate complex situations effectively.

New York’s tenant rights in the eviction process

As a New York landlord, being aware of tenant rights during eviction is important for legal compliance. Here are essential points to consider:

1. Warranty of habitability: Tenants have the right to a livable space. Significant violations could be used as a defense against eviction.
2. Rent receipt law: Upon request, you must provide written rent receipts for payments made in cash, money order, or any form other than personal check.
3. Constructive eviction: Tenants may claim this if your actions substantially interfere with their use of the property, potentially voiding their obligation to pay rent.
4. Fair Housing protections: Evictions cannot be based on a tenant's membership in a protected class, including source of income in many jurisdictions.
5. Right to organize: Tenants can form, join, or participate in tenant organizations without fear of retaliation.
6. Domestic violence protections: Special provisions exist for tenants who are victims of domestic violence, potentially affecting eviction proceedings.
7. Military service considerations: Active duty service members have additional protections under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act.
8. Senior citizen protections: Some jurisdictions offer additional eviction protections for elderly tenants.

Understanding these rights helps ensure your eviction process is legal and ethical. Always consult with a legal professional for the most up-to-date advice regarding your situation.

How Azibo can Help You Avoid Eviction Situations

Managing tenants and avoiding potential eviction scenarios requires the right tools to streamline processes and mitigate risks. Azibo provides landlords with comprehensive property management solutions that reduce the likelihood of tenant issues and ensure smooth operations. Here’s how Azibo can help:

• Tenant screening: Avoid problem tenants by using Azibo’s tenant screening tools, which allow you to check for previous evictions, criminal records, and credit history. This ensures you’re selecting reliable tenants right from the start.

• New York-specific lease agreements: Azibo offers customizable lease agreements that help you comply with New York’s unique landlord-tenant laws. By using compliant agreements, you can prevent lease violations that may lead to disputes or eviction.

• Document storage: Azibo’s secure document storage ensures that all important records — such as lease agreements, notices, maintenance requests, and communications — are easily accessible. This not only helps with organization but also protects you in case of legal disputes.

• Maintenance and messaging: Azibo provides a centralized platform for managing tenant communications and maintenance requests, reducing miscommunication and improving tenant satisfaction. Keeping tenants happy and addressing issues promptly can prevent escalations that lead to eviction.

• Accounting and rent collection: With Azibo’s accounting features, you can track rent payments, automate late fees, and maintain clear financial records. By having an organized system, you can identify payment issues early and address them before they lead to eviction.

Using Azibo to streamline tenant management and comply with the law helps minimize the chances of eviction, saving both time and money while protecting your investment.

Sign up for free, today.

Complex eviction laws in New York — Explained

Navigating evictions in New York requires knowledge of legal procedures, tenant rights, and landlord responsibilities. Communication, proper documentation, and exploring alternatives to eviction are important steps in managing rental disputes effectively. 

Both landlords and tenants benefit from knowing the ins and outs of the eviction process, from valid grounds for eviction to the importance of adhering to specific timelines and legal requirements.

Remember, eviction should be a last resort. By approaching rental issues with willingness to find mutual solutions, many eviction situations can be avoided. When eviction becomes necessary, following the proper legal channels ensures a fair process for all parties. 

For complex cases, seeking professional legal advice is always a good idea.